Last updated
28 questions with answers
Which statement correctly describes the difference between Quebec's legal system and the common law system used in the rest of Canada?
- A.Quebec relies mainly on precedent; others codify private law
- B.Quebec codifies private law; others rely mainly on precedent
- C.Quebec uses the common law; only its court language differs
- D.Quebec codifies criminal law; others leave crime to precedent
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: BQuebec codifies private law; others rely mainly on precedent
Why B is right
Canada has two systems of private law. Quebec's private law, covering contracts, property and civil liability, rests on the Civil Code of Quebec, a comprehensive written code from the French civil tradition. Quebec judges still use earlier decisions to interpret the Code, but the Code is the starting point. The other nine provinces and the three territories use the common law, where much of the governing law comes from judges' decisions built up over time as precedent.
Why the other options are wrong
- AOption A: This reverses the two systems: Quebec's private law is codified, and it is the common law provinces and territories that rely mainly on precedent.
- COption C: Quebec's civil law is a different legal system, not the common law conducted in French.
- DOption D: Criminal law is federal and codified in the Criminal Code for all of Canada; the Civil Code of Quebec governs private law.
Key principle: Quebec uses a codified civil law system for private law, while the rest of Canada uses common law built on precedent.
Devi, P.Eng., is retained by a law firm as an expert witness in a construction dispute. The lawyer, hoping to strengthen the client's case, asks her to leave out a technical finding that weakens the client's position. What is Devi's most appropriate response?
- A.Decline and give her complete opinion
- B.Comply and leave the gap to cross examination
- C.Withdraw from the case and return the fee
- D.Add the finding if the other expert raises it
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: ADecline and give her complete opinion
Why A is right
An expert witness owes her overriding duty to the court or tribunal, not to the party paying her fee. Leaving out a technical finding because it weakens the client's case would turn her into an advocate and give the court an incomplete opinion. Devi should decline the request and give her complete, objective opinion. If the omission came out on cross examination, it would also damage the client's case and her own credibility far more than the finding itself.
Why the other options are wrong
- BOption B: The other side being able to expose weaknesses in cross examination does not excuse her; her own opinion must be complete and honest.
- COption C: Withdrawing is unnecessary, because she can simply refuse the improper request and give her full opinion.
- DOption D: Making the finding depend on what the opposing expert raises still leaves the court with a shaded opinion.
Key principle: An expert witness owes a paramount duty of neutrality and completeness to the court, not to the party who retained them.
An engineer at a private engineering firm believes she was passed over for promotion because of her religion. She wants to take formal action. Which route fits her situation?
- A.A complaint under provincial human rights legislation
- B.A complaint to Engineers Canada
- C.A criminal charge under the Criminal Code
- D.A claim that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms was breached
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: AA complaint under provincial human rights legislation
B goes to a national body with no power over employment disputes.
C treats a human rights matter as a crime.
D is the trap. The Charter restrains government, and her employer is a private firm.
A is right. Discrimination by a private employer on a protected ground falls under provincial human rights law.
- A: Private employer: human rights law.
- B: Wrong body entirely.
- C: Not a criminal matter.
- D: The Charter restrains government only.
Two weeks before a fixed price deadline, a client verbally asks an engineering firm for a significant addition to the scope. The client says not to worry about paperwork, the fee will be sorted out later. What should the project engineer do before proceeding?
- A.Proceed, since a verbal agreement is good enough
- B.Confirm the change, its fee and timing in writing
- C.Refuse any change to the scope
- D.Proceed, and add the extra fee to the final invoice
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: BConfirm the change, its fee and timing in writing
A is the trap. The written fixed price contract still governs, and nothing records the change or its fee.
C refuses a reasonable request. Changes are normal. They just need to be recorded.
D is how firms end up unpaid. The client can point to the fixed price.
B is right. Record the added scope, the extra fee, and the new date in writing before doing the work.
- A: The written contract still governs.
- B: Put the change in writing first.
- C: Changes are fine, once recorded.
- D: The client can point to the fixed price.
While a tender call is open, the engineer administering it finds that the quantities in the tender documents are wrong. Bids close in a week. What is the most appropriate action?
- A.Tell only the owner, and let the owner decide what to do
- B.Fix it later, through change orders after award
- C.Correct it by addendum issued to every bidder
- D.Quietly tell only the lowest bidder
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: CCorrect it by addendum issued to every bidder
A leaves the bidders pricing on wrong numbers.
B is the trap. Bids would be priced on wrong information, and fixing it later is unfair to every bidder.
D gives one bidder an unfair advantage.
C is right. Everyone prices on the same, corrected information.
- A: Bidders still price wrong numbers.
- B: Unfair to every bidder.
- C: Same correction, to everyone.
- D: One bidder gets an unfair edge.
A contractor on a fixed price job faces material shortages that double its costs and stretch the schedule. It tells the owner the contract is frustrated, and it is walking away. Which statement is most accurate?
- A.Frustrated, because costs rose by more than half
- B.The owner must renegotiate the price
- C.The contract is frustrated, so both sides are released
- D.Not frustrated. Higher cost and delay are not enough
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DNot frustrated. Higher cost and delay are not enough
A invents a percentage test that does not exist.
B puts an obligation on the owner that the law does not impose.
C is the trap. Higher cost and delay make it harder, not radically different.
D is right. Hardship, delay or loss alone never frustrates a contract.
- A: There is no percentage test.
- B: No duty to renegotiate.
- C: Harder is not radically different.
- D: Hardship alone never frustrates.
A contractor prices its bid using tender drawings prepared by an engineering firm hired by the owner. The drawings contain errors, and the contractor loses money. The contractor never had a contract with the engineering firm. Which statement is most accurate?
- A.The firm owed a duty of care to bidders who relied on it
- B.Only the owner can be sued, since it hired the firm
- C.Only the engineers who sealed the drawings can be held liable
- D.It cannot sue the firm, because there was no contract
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: AThe firm owed a duty of care to bidders who relied on it
B ignores the duty the firm itself owed to those relying on its work.
C misreads the seal. In Edgeworth Construction, the leading case on these facts, the sealing engineers were not held personally liable.
D is the trap. Negligence does not need a contract.
A is right. Canada's top court found exactly that in Edgeworth Construction.
- A: Duty to the bidders who relied on it.
- B: The firm owed its own duty.
- C: The seal did not make them personally liable.
- D: Negligence does not need a contract.
A junior engineer at a design firm miscalculates a load path. The firm's peer review should have caught it, but the senior reviewer signed off without a detailed check. The error is found after construction, and remediation is costly. Which view of liability is most appropriate?
- A.Only the junior engineer is liable, personally
- B.The firm is vicariously liable for the error
- C.No one, since peer review is only an internal step
- D.The client, since it reviewed and accepted the design
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: BThe firm is vicariously liable for the error
A is the trap. It ignores the firm's liability for its employee's negligence at work.
C pretends an internal process removes liability. It does not.
D shifts the firm's error onto the client.
B is right. The firm, as employer, answers for the negligence of its employees in the course of their work.
- A: Ignores the employer's liability.
- B: Vicarious liability: the firm answers.
- C: An internal step removes nothing.
- D: The client did not make the error.
Within four years of completion, a building an engineer supervised in Quebec partly collapses. The owner sues, and the engineer expects the owner to prove fault, as in Ontario. Which statement is most accurate?
- A.The burden is shared equally by owner and engineer
- B.The owner must prove the engineer was at fault
- C.The engineer must prove there was no fault
- D.Only the contractor can be liable in Quebec
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: CThe engineer must prove there was no fault
A splits the burden. Quebec's five year rule puts it on the engineer, not on both sides.
B is the trap. That is the common law habit. Quebec's five year rule flips it.
D forgets that the supervising engineer is liable with the contractor.
C is right. Within five years, the engineer who supervised the work carries the burden.
- A: The presumption falls on the engineer.
- B: The burden is flipped in Quebec.
- C: The engineer must prove no fault.
- D: The engineer is liable too.
An employer finds that an engineer has been submitting inflated expense reports for months, and dismisses him without notice. He argues his technical work was always rated satisfactory. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
- A.He must first receive a written warning
- B.Only a criminal conviction would justify dismissal
- C.He is owed reasonable notice, since his work was satisfactory
- D.The dismissal is for just cause, because of dishonesty
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DThe dismissal is for just cause, because of dishonesty
A applies the rule for ordinary underperformance to dishonesty.
B sets a bar the law does not require.
C is the trap. Good technical work does not cancel serious dishonesty.
D is right. Serious dishonesty is just cause, so no notice is owed.
- A: Warnings are for ordinary underperformance.
- B: No conviction needed.
- C: Good work does not cancel dishonesty.
- D: Dishonesty is just cause.
A one time client has stopped responding entirely, and is refusing to pay an invoice it does not dispute. There is no arbitration clause in the contract. Which route is most appropriate?
- A.Litigation, to recover the unpaid fee
- B.Arbitration, as the fastest option
- C.Keep negotiating until the client replies
- D.Mediation, to preserve the relationship
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: ALitigation, to recover the unpaid fee
B has no basis here. Arbitration binds only parties who agreed to it.
C waits on a party that has stopped talking.
D is the trap. Mediation needs two willing sides, and this client will not engage.
A is right. With an unresponsive party and no arbitration clause, court is the route that works.
- A: Unresponsive party: litigation.
- B: No agreement, no arbitration.
- C: You cannot negotiate with silence.
- D: Mediation needs a willing partner.
A client paid an engineering firm in full for drawings of a pump station, and now wants to reuse them on a second site. The contract says nothing about intellectual property. Who owns the copyright in the drawings?
- A.The client, because it paid for them
- B.The engineering firm, since nothing was assigned
- C.Nobody, because engineering drawings cannot be copyrighted
- D.The public, once the project is built
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: BThe engineering firm, since nothing was assigned
A is the trap. Paying the fee buys the service and a licence to use the drawings for their purpose, not the copyright.
C is simply wrong. Drawings and reports are protected works.
D confuses copyright with an expired patent.
B is right. Without an express assignment, copyright stays with the engineer or the employer.
- A: Paying buys a licence, not copyright.
- B: No assignment, no transfer.
- C: Drawings are protected.
- D: Building it does not end copyright.
A homeowner's lawyer hires a structural engineer to assess a cracked foundation. She concludes ordinary soil settlement is the most likely cause, not poor workmanship. The lawyer asks her to write the report so it emphasizes the workmanship theory instead. What is the most appropriate response?
- A.Agree, if the fee rises when the case is won
- B.Rewrite it to emphasize workmanship, as the client asked
- C.Keep her independent opinion, and report what she found
- D.Withdraw, and say nothing about why
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: CKeep her independent opinion, and report what she found
A adds a contingent fee, which can get the opinion excluded, and bring discipline.
B is the trap. Her duty is to the court, not to the side that pays her.
D abandons the work rather than giving the honest opinion she owes.
C is right. She reports her honest, independent opinion, whoever it helps.
- A: A contingent fee is disqualifying.
- B: Her duty runs to the court.
- C: Independent, whoever it helps.
- D: She owes an honest opinion.
A contractor tells a junior engineer that its performance bond works just like insurance. If it ever defaults, he says, the surety simply pays, and that is the end of it. Which statement is most accurate?
- A.The bond protects the contractor from claims
- B.The surety pays only if the owner was at fault
- C.He is right, a performance bond is a form of insurance
- D.The surety pays, then recovers from the contractor
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DThe surety pays, then recovers from the contractor
A has it backwards. The bond protects the owner.
B invents a condition. The surety's obligation arises on the contractor's default.
C is the trap. A bond guarantees the owner. It does not forgive the contractor.
D is right. The surety pays the owner, then pursues the contractor and its indemnitors.
- A: The bond protects the owner.
- B: It is triggered by default.
- C: A bond is not insurance.
- D: The surety comes back for its money.
A Canadian civil engineer gets a work visa for a consulting job with a firm in the United States. She plans to start sealing drawings right away, the way she does in her home province. What is the most appropriate action?
- A.Obtain the licence that state requires first
- B.Use her Canadian seal, since the firm is satisfied
- C.Seal under a colleague's name until she is licensed
- D.Start sealing, since the visa lets her work there
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: AObtain the licence that state requires first
B relies on the employer. The firm's satisfaction does not license her there.
C lends someone else's seal to her work. Never acceptable.
D is the trap. A visa authorizes work, not engineering practice.
A is right. She needs that jurisdiction's own licence before practising or sealing.
- A: Their licence first.
- B: Her employer cannot license her.
- C: Never someone else's seal.
- D: A visa authorizes work, not practice.
A company is charged with an environmental offence after a spill. Its defence is a written environmental policy, adopted years ago. There are no audits, no training records, and no follow up. Which statement is most accurate?
- A.The written policy, once adopted, proves due diligence
- B.Due diligence needs an active, monitored system
- C.No defence is possible to an environmental charge
- D.Only the employee who caused the spill can be charged
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: BDue diligence needs an active, monitored system
A is the trap. A policy on paper, never put to work, is not due diligence.
C goes too far. Due diligence is a real defence, when it is proven.
D ignores the liability of the company itself.
B is right. Courts look for audits, training and follow up that were actually done.
- A: A policy alone is not a system.
- B: Show the system working.
- C: Due diligence is a real defence.
- D: The company is liable too.
Before a scheduled concrete pour, an engineer finds the formwork cross bracing falls short of the applicable standard. The site supervisor urges her to approve the pour anyway, and fix the bracing afterward, to avoid a costly delay. What is the most appropriate action?
- A.Leave the decision to the supervisor, since cost is his call
- B.Approve the pour, and have the bracing fixed after
- C.Withhold approval until the bracing is corrected
- D.Approve, but record the supervisor's pressure in writing
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: CWithhold approval until the bracing is corrected
A hands a safety call to the person pushing to skip it. Directing work carries her own duty.
B is the trap. It puts the schedule ahead of a known hazard, with workers at risk.
D documents the pressure, and still approves something unsafe.
C is right. Explain the deficiency and the risk, and require the fix before the pour, escalating if pressure continues.
- A: Her duty is personal.
- B: Schedule over a known hazard.
- C: No pour until it is fixed.
- D: A record does not make it safe.
A firm's human resources team asks every job applicant, even for entry level drafting jobs, for a detailed medical and family history, in case it is useful someday. An engineer on the hiring committee is uneasy. What is the most appropriate action?
- A.Collect it, but keep it locked away
- B.Collect it only from senior applicants
- C.Go along with it, since more information can help
- D.Flag that it collects far more than the job needs
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DFlag that it collects far more than the job needs
A protects the data, but the problem is collecting it at all.
B narrows it, but still collects what no job needs.
C is the trap. Collecting more than the stated purpose needs breaches privacy principles.
D is right. Personal information should be collected only for a stated purpose, and only as much as that purpose needs.
- A: The problem is collecting it.
- B: Still more than any job needs.
- C: More than needed is a breach.
- D: Collect only what the purpose needs.
An engineer designing infrastructure near traditional Indigenous lands finds that construction may disrupt culturally significant land use and water access. Permits are issued, and the client says consultation is a legal issue, not an engineering one. What is the most appropriate response?
- A.Report the client to the regulator for unlawful conduct
- B.Withdraw quietly from the project, and tell no one why
- C.Proceed as designed, since the permits have been issued
- D.Explain the impacts, and advise meaningful consultation
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DExplain the impacts, and advise meaningful consultation
A jumps to a report, when nothing unlawful has happened and the client has not been advised.
B walks away without telling anyone what she found.
C is the trap. A permit does not make the impact disappear, and the engineer has seen it.
D is right. She explains the impacts clearly, and why meaningful consultation manages the risk.
- A: Nothing to report yet.
- B: Silence helps no one.
- C: A permit does not erase the impact.
- D: Explain the impacts. Advise consultation.
After bids close, an owner tells the second lowest bidder the low price, and offers it the job if it beats that number. What is this?
- A.Ordinary negotiation
- B.Quantum meruit
- C.Bid rigging
- D.Bid shopping
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DBid shopping
A is the trap. Using one bid to drive down another is not ordinary negotiation.
D is right. It is bid shopping, unethical and a likely breach of Contract A.
- A: Not ordinary negotiation.
- B: A payment for work done.
- C: Collusion among bidders, not the owner.
- D: Bid shopping.
A province wide strike stops deliveries to a site, and the contract has a force majeure clause. What is the contractor usually entitled to?
- A.More time to finish
- B.Extra payment for the delay
- C.To end the contract for frustration
- D.Liquidated damages from the owner
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: AMore time to finish
B is the trap. These clauses usually give time, not compensation.
A is right. A force majeure event usually brings more time, not more money.
- A: More time, not money.
- B: Usually time, not money.
- C: Frustration is hard to prove here.
- D: That runs the other way.
An employee engineer designs a floor negligently, and the client sues the employing firm. Which term explains why the firm can be liable?
- A.Strict liability
- B.Joint and several liability
- C.Concurrent liability
- D.Vicarious liability
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DVicarious liability
B is the trap. It is about several parties sharing one loss.
D is right. The employer answers for its employee's negligence at work.
- A: About dangerous escapes.
- B: About several parties.
- C: Contract and tort at once.
- D: The employer answers.
A company has kept a process secret for decades. A competitor works out the same process independently. Which statement is most accurate?
- A.Copyright protects the process
- B.The competitor infringes the trade secret
- C.The competitor is free to use the process
- D.The company can sue the competitor for patent infringement
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: CThe competitor is free to use the process
B is the trap. A trade secret gives no protection against independent discovery.
C is right. Independent development is the classic weak point of a trade secret.
- A: Copyright does not cover a process.
- B: No protection against independent discovery.
- C: Independent development is allowed.
- D: It was never patented.
A subcontractor, short of cash, tells a general contractor it will walk off the job unless its price goes up. Nothing justifies the increase, and there is no time to replace it. The contractor reluctantly agrees. How is this best described?
- A.Frustration of the contract
- B.An ordinary renegotiation
- C.A valid price change, since both sides agreed
- D.Economic duress
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DEconomic duress
C is the trap. Agreement under illegitimate pressure is not free agreement.
D is right. An illegitimate threat left the contractor no realistic choice.
- A: Nothing frustrated the contract.
- B: It was a threat, not a negotiation.
- C: Agreement under pressure is not free.
- D: An illegitimate threat, no real choice.
A specialized engineer signed a covenant barring her from her field anywhere across most of the province for two years after leaving. She resigns and joins a competitor. Is the covenant likely to hold up?
- A.Yes, because she signed it
- B.No, because it is wider than is reasonable
- C.Yes, because she joined a competitor
- D.Only if her employer pays her during the two years
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: BNo, because it is wider than is reasonable
A is the trap. Courts do not enforce a covenant just because it was signed.
B is right. A covenant that sweeps too wide, in area or time, is likely unenforceable.
- A: Signing is not enough.
- B: Too broad to be reasonable.
- C: The covenant must be reasonable.
- D: No such condition.
A geoscientist preparing the technical report for a mining company's public resource estimate is asked to use the most optimistic assumptions the data could possibly support. What is the most appropriate action?
- A.Use them, with a footnote that management chose them
- B.Let management sign the report instead
- C.Use the optimistic assumptions, as management asked
- D.Use the assumptions she can professionally defend
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: DUse the assumptions she can professionally defend
C is the trap. Her name on a misleading report carries personal liability.
D is right. The qualified person stands behind assumptions she can defend.
- A: A footnote does not fix it.
- B: Management is not the qualified person.
- C: Her name carries personal liability.
- D: Only what she can defend.
An engineering firm has a healthy, long running relationship with a repeat client, and they disagree about how to read a technical specification. Which first step fits best?
- A.Report the client to the regulator
- B.Start a lawsuit, to settle it for good
- C.Negotiate, and bring in a mediator if needed
- D.Refuse to continue until the client gives in
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: CNegotiate, and bring in a mediator if needed
B is the trap. It damages a good relationship over a disagreement the parties can work through.
C is right. Willing parties with a good relationship start with negotiation or mediation.
- A: Not misconduct.
- B: Too adversarial, too soon.
- C: Talk first. Mediate if needed.
- D: Leverage, not resolution.
A subcontractor, unpaid on a private project, misses the deadline to preserve its construction lien. Which statement is most accurate?
- A.The lien is lost, but a contract claim survives
- B.It can file the lien late with a fee
- C.The owner must pay it anyway
- D.The debt is cancelled along with the lien rights
Show the answer and explanation
Correct answer: AThe lien is lost, but a contract claim survives
D is the trap. Losing the lien does not cancel the debt.
A is right. It can still sue the party that hired it, in contract.
- A: The contract claim survives.
- B: The deadlines are strict.
- C: The lien rights are gone.
- D: The debt survives.
Where these questions come from
Most are worked through on camera in our free NPPE master class; the rest are from our free sample set. The words they lean on are explained in the NPPE glossary. A free account adds 60 practice questions and a timed mini exam, and Basic opens the full bank and the 110 question simulator.
Free accountNo card needed
60 practice questions and a timed mini exam, free
- 60 questions weighted like the real exam
- An 82 minute mini exam, scored by section
- Section I of the study guide in full
- Basic: over 1,400 questions and full mock exams with no limit